For those who don't know her, Cynthia Tucker is a Pulitzer Prize winning columnist with the Atlanta Journal Constitution. The AJC like many other large newspapers leans to the left (as does Ms Tucker) and has suffered declining readership for some time.
In the mind of Cynthia Tucker, recent grumblings of secession by GOP gubernatorial hopefuls, is
treason. In fact such treachery is inspired by no other reason than the election of our nation's first Black president. The racial implications not withstanding, the assertion that only a traitor would embrace the dormant notion of secession is ludicrous. Is Ms. Tucker familiar with the once cherished principle of "consent of the governed" or perhaps she has forgotten the notion of
"self-determination" and long ignored is the concept of "freedom of choice."
Granted these GOP politicians speak more of secession in the hopes of gaining political traction in a period where Republican governance in Georgia has left much to
be desired, but in their politicking they have touched on a truism that is no less relevant today than in was when the United States was in its infancy and that truth is the inescapable fact that all people are born free and should
be free to choose their government and its leaders.
Our loyalty should NOT
be to the United States as an entity but to the ideals
this nation supposedly upholds and cherishes.
If those ideals were to
be abandoned by the nation, who would dare question a person's desire to break free of such tyranny. While no one is arguing that the United States has degenerated into dictatorship it has for some ventured far beyond its desired framework. While some might view the direction our country has taken as necessary and perhaps benevolent, is it no less tyrannical to impel someone's participation when it conflicts with their own sense of freedom. Throughout history there have been many nations who have, at the point of the sword (and later the gun) forced people to live under their rule, regardless of their consent, nations like the Soviet Union and Cuba come to mind. And that
is indeed tyranny.
Is it
treason to want to choose your own path
if you feel the choices of others are not to your liking, is it
treason to believe as John Locke did that a government lacks legitimacy without the consent of the governed? Is it
treason to resist having someone else's will imposed upon you?
if it is, then one must remember the immortal words of Patrick Henry: "...
if this be treason, make the most of it."
Links:http://www.ajc.com/services/content/printedition/2009/05/27/tucked0527.html